Superintendent Barnett Delivers Hats Off Performance On First Report Card

by | May 23, 2017 | Breaking News, County News, Cullman, People, Politics, School Board, Students

image by: Sherea Harris

Superintendent Barnett Delivers Hats Off Performance On First Report Card

Cullman County Board of Education’s (CCBoE) fateful decision in March of 2016 to hire a local newcomer superintendent to salvage a previously negative leadership situation was empirically valididated Monday night.

The Cullman County Board of Education (CCBoE) recently hired the Alabama Association of School Boards (AASB) to assess the performance of their Superintendent of schools.

On Monday evening, CCBoE released the results of AASB’s 2016-2017 evaluation of Superintendent Shane Barnette.

Barnette’s professional performance review was p0lled from two separate groups:

★ The 7-member Cullman County School Board

★ 37 Top School System Administrators

Respondents in each group were asked to rank a comprehensive, in-depth roster of questions based upon a classic 1 through 5 grading scale:

1 – Unsatisfactory
2 – Needs Improvement
3 – Satisfactory
4 – Above Average
5 – Excellent

The aggregate average grades across all areas of evaluation for Superintendent Barnette were reported as follows

4.0 (Above Average) – from all School Board members
4.4 (above Above Average) – from all top School Administrators

This assessment is Barnette’s first AASB ‘report card’ after concluding his first full year as County Schools superintendent.

Barnette was appointed as superintendent in March 2016 replacing well-liked interim leader Brandon Payne who – to the surprise of many – left the school system to serve in the private sector. In hindsight, Payne’s short term in office acted as a crucial stop-gap following the controversial departure of former Superintendent Craig Ross in late 2015.

For comparison purposes, Ross’ last report card in 2015 delivered the following results:

• 3.5 (above Satisfactory) – from all School Board members
• 4.2 (above Above Average) – from all top School Administrators

This year’s report card reveals the 7-member CCBoE approved of Barnette’s performance significantly more than they did of Dr. Ross efforts.

Top administrators also positively endorsed the first-time superintendent’s work in 2016-17 out polling Ross by .2.

The AASB provides a diverse array of critical functions for education across the state. One of its most important missions is the administration, collection, assessment, evaluation and public presentation of each Alabama school system Superintendent’s performance.

This process is time consuming, complex and mathematically intricate.

In the case of Mr. Bartnette, the Alabama Association of School Boards presented the seven (7) Cullman School Board members with an evaluation questionnaire in earlier in the year (all board members responded).

A slightly modified and less complicated version of this assessment questionnaire was provided to top Cullman County School Administrators and Central Office Staff.

This assessment survey is/was extensive. It delved into almost every conceivable aspect of Barnette’s professional responsibilities and performance inside the school system.

School Board members and administrators provided written, accurate answers about Dr. Ross’ performance to the independent AASB organization.

It was an anonymous process; the answers associated with their names were NOT revealed to Superintendent Barnette. This anonymity eliminates the possibility of favoritism, bias, and concerns of retribution for low ratings.

The AASB’s methodology and execution of their evaluations over the years has been accepted statewide as accurate, fair and illuminating.

While we do not have AASB assessment results from other first-time superintendents from around the state, Barnette’s strong 2016-17 report card speaks for itself.

The results validate the CCBoE’s fateful decision to hire a local newcomer to salvage a previously negative superintendent situation. Hats off to Superintendent Barnett.

Cullman County Schools

Most Recent Stories On Cullman Today

Kernel Kullman 2017 Christmas Giveaway

Kernel Cullman 2017 Christmas Giveaway As you walk in the door to music of the swing era and see rows of nostalgic candy, glass bottled soft drinks sitting in ice, homemade fudge, and of course our mainstay of over 70 delicious flavors of gourmet popcorn. You will be...

Marlana Johnson Classy to Sassy 2017 Christmas Giveaway

Marlana Johnson Classy to Sassy 2017 Christmas Giveaway Classy to Sassy, LLC is one of Cullman’s finest women’s clothing boutiques. So fine in fact, that they received a few high honors from recent ‘The Best of Local’ contests. Not only are they a boutique, they also...

Makers Market 2017 Christmas Giveaway

Makers Market 2017 Christmas Giveaway Makers Market is a curated craft fair for local makers, artists, and vendors who create special handmade items. This is a craft market unlike any other and you do not want to miss this unique shopping opportunity! So far, there...

Late Urban Surge Seals Doug Jones US Senate Victory

Late Urban Surge Seals Doug Jones US Senate Victory The population centers of Birmingham (68/30), Montgomery (72/27), Huntsville (57/40), Mobile (56/42), and Tuscaloosa (57/41) have put Democrat Doug Jones into the United States Senate in a big win over Republican Roy...

The Lakeside Life 2017 Christmas Giveaway

The Lakeside Life 2017 Christmas Giveaway The Lakeside Life is a lake living lifestyle magazine featuring beautiful Smith Lake. The Lakeside Life team is committed to showcasing Lewis Smith Lake like never before! Their premiere issue was released in October and will...

Jennifer Rochelle Photography 2017 Christmas Giveaway

Jennifer Rochelle Photography 2017 Christmas Giveaway Hello friends! My name is Jennifer Rochelle. I am one of those free-spirited and wild-hearted women that loves to laugh and hates to do laundry. My life is characterized by equal portions of passion and chaos. I'm...
Superintendent Barnett Delivers Hats Off Performance On First Report Card

Staff Writers

The staff writers at Cullman Today are a collaborative group of citizen reporters sharing the writing of stories based upon their personal interests and work schedules.

Latest posts by Staff Writers (see all)